Today’s the last day of this year’s
ibarw (International Blog Against Racism Week) – not that you shouldn’t blog against racism all year around, of course. And this time I’ve actually had something I’ve been wanting to say, but it’s taken me all week to figure out how to say it.
hyaenid once brought up a point on whether she was allowed to identify as POC and, among other things, asked, “Is it cultural appropriation when it’s my own damn culture?”
My first answer was, of course not! At least, not for identifying as POC, which I personally see as an oppositional and wide-spread term that’s more about being not-white (and not having all the privileges associated with whiteness), just as “queer” is about being not-straight. But the question stuck in my mind, the idea that one can not only do a disservice to their own culture by misrepresenting it but actually
appropriate it, and I’ve been applying it to many other issues and problems that come up in my mind. Which, actually, has happened a lot more often than I would’ve expected, especially in the past year or so.
See, I’m not white. I’m first generation Indian-American. But my parents never made a huge deal of impressing their cultures on me, even giving up on speaking their languages to me after I went to school and learned English, and we never lived in an area with a large Indian community. Most of my friends were non-Indian, so I spent a lot of my life thinking of myself as “not really Indian” and “almost-white” in my perspective. (I used to hate the term ABCD – “American-Born Confused Desi” – but I think after all this time I do have to admit to some amount of confusion.)
But – I’m really, really not white. What I am is excessively privileged in other ways: in socio-economic class, education, physical ability, identifying as cis-gendered, and in living in a place where my rights as a minority in race, gender, sexual orientation, religious identification (or, uh, lack thereof) are
generally respected.
( more on Slumdog Millionaire, Avatar, and cultural appropriation from all directions )